The decision was the first of many ruthless choices made in Episodes 1 through 3 by both Faithfuls and Traitors. By the end of Episode 3, two contestants had been banished while two more were secretly murdered in the night by the Traitors.

"The Traitors" dropped the first three episodes of Season 3 on Peacock on Thursday night, giving viewers a taste of the treachery and murders to come.

Unfortunately for Bach Nation, the Bachelor in Paradise bartender became the first player voted out on season 3. Wells tried his best to fit in with the group, but in the end, an accusation from Robyn was enough to send him packing, with Carolyn casting the final vote.